OT review, Shure E2 Personal Monitor "canal-phones" [Archive] - DIY Mobile Audio - Now with Violent Bass Air!!

PDA

View Full Version : OT review, Shure E2 Personal Monitor "canal-phones"


chad
06-26-2006, 09:10 PM
This may or may not have interest to you guys but I thought I'd share anyway. I really only use headphones for 2 things. Mowing the yard and mixing live (cueing, etc) My live headphones are Sony MDRV700's Although not the pinnacle of accuracy they play low and play loud and don't sound bad at all. In the studio I use Sony 7506's or Sennheiser HD680's.

Last year I talked myself into buying an MP3 player for myself for my birthday. I bought an iRiver H10 20GB (love it, BTW). It came with some Sennheiser ear buds. Although not bad sounding ear buds I found them to make my ears hurt like hell after mowing 3 acres and they were open air designs so I had to play them louder than I wanted to in order to get over the mower. I was getting ringing when done and if I'm tearing up my hearing I'm doing it while doing something I enjoy :) I had contemplated buying some in-ear style headphones since the day i bought it but was afraid to drop the cash. I worked as a monitor engineer for a LONG time and was very spoiled with high end in-ears. I kinda felt that if I did not spend a fortune that I would hate them, the Sensaphonics I used were NOT cheap BTW but sounded AWESOME! So did the Shure E5's that were also my de-facto. I never liked the E1's as they were too middy and really only worked well for guitar players and singers, I always had to EQ the hell out of them to my liking. All the above mentioned were used with custom molds not foamies.

So cutting to the chase. Friday afternoon was the beginning of mowing hell. I woke up Friday morning to find my Sennheiser stock buds in multiple pieces all over the floor. It seems that Punja the War Tiger (my female cat, bitchy) decided that they either tasted good or that I said "huh?" too many times after mowing. This prompted me to do a race inspired research session on affordable in-ears that could be obtained that day. There was no way in hell I was wearing the big Sony's in 90+ degree heat and fish-water like humidity. Best buy sells them for 100 bucks. Hint, MI retailers (music stores) and other pro outlets get a huge discount from Sure for quantity ordering and most of the time Shure sells to them ANYTHING for "end column" Shure is really good at helping the private retailer so calling the local music store scored me them for 85 bucks. Well, an un-disclosed amount less since I worked for them full time for 5 years and still do contract work for them, but, street price.... 85 bucks.

This was money well spent! They sound great! if you aren't used to the style of headphone then you will feel weird putting them in at first but practice makes perfect. On an affordable consumer level these are the best sounding bud-style headphones I have ever heard. Isolation is great even using foamies. I found the plastic ones to be uncomfortable and the silicone is OK but harder to get a seal. Once a good seal is obtained the low end is quite nice. They could use a tad more tippy top end but the more expensive ones provide that. A tickle on the iRiver EQ fixed it right quick, only like a dB or two. They are also quite revealing, more so than I thought they would be. They absolutely SMOKE the older E1's at half the price. The cable is much more durable, a bit heavy but they are built to last. Another nice thing is that you can touch the cable without the sound being transmitted to the ears like a stethoscope (WAY COOL) they are also 16 Ohms so they will play INSANELY loud if need be. I wanged them out and could not get distortion then my common sense said that they were way too loud.

So I mowed the yard, it looks great and was a MUCH more pleasurable experience than rattling my brains with an open air design. If you are looking for a great set of PEM's without breaking the bank I highly recommend them, hit your local music store up, support the local music scene and enjoy!

Chad

bassfromspace
06-27-2006, 12:06 AM
This may or may not have interest to you guys but I thought I'd share anyway. I really only use headphones for 2 things. Mowing the yard and mixing live (cueing, etc) My live headphones are Sony MDRV700's Although not the pinnacle of accuracy they play low and play loud and don't sound bad at all. In the studio I use Sony 7506's or Sennheiser HD680's.

Last year I talked myself into buying an MP3 player for myself for my birthday. I bought an iRiver H10 20GB (love it, BTW). It came with some Sennheiser ear buds. Although not bad sounding ear buds I found them to make my ears hurt like hell after mowing 3 acres and they were open air designs so I had to play them louder than I wanted to in order to get over the mower. I was getting ringing when done and if I'm tearing up my hearing I'm doing it while doing something I enjoy :) I had contemplated buying some in-ear style headphones since the day i bought it but was afraid to drop the cash. I worked as a monitor engineer for a LONG time and was very spoiled with high end in-ears. I kinda felt that if I did not spend a fortune that I would hate them, the Sensaphonics I used were NOT cheap BTW but sounded AWESOME! So did the Shure E5's that were also my de-facto. I never liked the E1's as they were too middy and really only worked well for guitar players and singers, I always had to EQ the hell out of them to my liking. All the above mentioned were used with custom molds not foamies.

So cutting to the chase. Friday afternoon was the beginning of mowing hell. I woke up Friday morning to find my Sennheiser stock buds in multiple pieces all over the floor. It seems that Punja the War Tiger (my female cat, bitchy) decided that they either tasted good or that I said "huh?" too many times after mowing. This prompted me to do a race inspired research session on affordable in-ears that could be obtained that day. There was no way in hell I was wearing the big Sony's in 90+ degree heat and fish-water like humidity. Best buy sells them for 100 bucks. Hint, MI retailers (music stores) and other pro outlets get a huge discount from Sure for quantity ordering and most of the time Shure sells to them ANYTHING for "end column" Shure is really good at helping the private retailer so calling the local music store scored me them for 85 bucks. Well, an un-disclosed amount less since I worked for them full time for 5 years and still do contract work for them, but, street price.... 85 bucks.

This was money well spent! They sound great! if you aren't used to the style of headphone then you will feel weird putting them in at first but practice makes perfect. On an affordable consumer level these are the best sounding bud-style headphones I have ever heard. Isolation is great even using foamies. I found the plastic ones to be uncomfortable and the silicone is OK but harder to get a seal. Once a good seal is obtained the low end is quite nice. They could use a tad more tippy top end but the more expensive ones provide that. A tickle on the iRiver EQ fixed it right quick, only like a dB or two. They are also quite revealing, more so than I thought they would be. They absolutely SMOKE the older E1's at half the price. The cable is much more durable, a bit heavy but they are built to last. Another nice thing is that you can touch the cable without the sound being transmitted to the ears like a stethoscope (WAY COOL) they are also 16 Ohms so they will play INSANELY loud if need be. I wanged them out and could not get distortion then my common sense said that they were way too loud.

So I mowed the yard, it looks great and was a MUCH more pleasurable experience than rattling my brains with an open air design. If you are looking for a great set of PEM's without breaking the bank I highly recommend them, hit your local music store up, support the local music scene and enjoy!

Chad

Nice review. I've been interested for a while now in a pair of in-ear bud's, but I can't bring myself to believe they'd be sufficient for the type of music I listen too.

I listen to rap 90% of the time, with r&b and jazz taking the rest of the pie, so excellent bass and extended high's are a must. My main 'phone's are a pair of mdr-v600's (and a pair of audio technica's which i hate) so I'm used to pretty good sound.

I may take the plunge and give them a try.

Thanks for the review.

chad
06-27-2006, 07:51 AM
I tried them out with some of the Techno/Minimal that I have mastered and some more popular hip-hop and the low end was there. It did not feel like they were going to jump out of your ears like the v600's can give the feeling of, but, the low end was much more than I expected from a small headphone. The seal is important, it needs to be totally in there or the low end drops off dramatically.

Headphone reviews are hard because they are tough to measure, they are very subjective. I like a more open, airy, and effortless top end. These arent as airy as the sony's but still have it there. It's not like they fall on their face on the tippy top end they are just voiced a bit different. I'd give them a shot. My impresson is that of many others in that you ain't going to get more low end for less than 4-5 bills.

Chad

bassfromspace
06-27-2006, 01:08 PM
I tried them out with some of the Techno/Minimal that I have mastered and some more popular hip-hop and the low end was there. It did not feel like they were going to jump out of your ears like the v600's can give the feeling of, but, the low end was much more than I expected from a small headphone. The seal is important, it needs to be totally in there or the low end drops off dramatically.

Headphone reviews are hard because they are tough to measure, they are very subjective. I like a more open, airy, and effortless top end. These arent as airy as the sony's but still have it there. It's not like they fall on their face on the tippy top end they are just voiced a bit different. I'd give them a shot. My impresson is that of many others in that you ain't going to get more low end for less than 4-5 bills.

Chad

Excellent.

I'll try and pick up a pair either today or tomorrow. If I begin to miss the bass too much, I can always connect my headphone amp.

Thanks again.

300Z
06-27-2006, 04:22 PM
Cool, Thanks Chad.

I think i gonna get a set too. My Altec IM716 are nice but the higher impedance takes the hit in the power and sometimes there isn't enough power to overcome the road noise. :(
If the bass on the E2 is as good as the IM716 i'll be very happy. With good power on tap the bass from the IM716 is quite good. I really like it. Thanks DS-21... ;)

Leo