DIYMobileAudio.com Car Stereo Forum banner

Morel Elate SW6 vs. Tannoy 5'' Bass speaker

19K views 13 replies 12 participants last post by  ryan roberts  
#1 ·
I blew one of my morel elate SW6 and needed a replacement. I had these Tannoy 5'' bass speakers (total diameter 6'') that really impressed me with sound. I picked them up in an assorted lot of speakers from Madison Wisconsin, and they had really no resale value, so I decided to install one.

Physical build

Morel Elates dominate here, they are well built, sturdy and attractive design.Their diameter is about 6.75'' and they are heavier and have a bigger voice coil.

Tannoy basket is actually made of plastic and seems quite breakable. I verified this when I was tightening the screws on the first speaker and it broke. I went ahead and installed the second one more carefully. It is 6'' diameter, and is deeper.

Sound
Amplifier used is a NVX JAD 900.5 supplying 60rms at 4 ohms and unspecified at 8 ohms.

The Morel Elates have very good sound. I honestly don't think it is good enough to justify their very high price, but it is warm and clear. It seems to lose some output in general below about 200hz, and starts to lose sound quality above 2000hz. They are able to handle very high power (but who plays their midrange at 200 watt RMS). They are about equal sound quality to the Dayton reference series, and below that of Dynaudio.

The Tannoys are 8 ohms. They clearly can play lower than the elates. The bass reproduction sounds more accurate. I tried various crossover points and the Tannoy's actually sound good across the entire frequency range! They are not as warm as the Elates, but honestly when I integrated them into my system (HPF 600 HZ, LPF 160HZ, but I tested at various crossover points), their sound quality was equal to the Elates, the voice was clear I can't find the specs anywhere so I have no idea what their max power handling is.

Conclusion

I feel like an idiot for spending so much money on the SW6. The Tannoys were a diamond in the rough.
 

Attachments

#2 · (Edited)
I am subscribing to this thread, I'd be curious to how people will respond to your findings. I to have auditioned the elate mids and have had a hard time justifying the price. The tweeters are fantastic but the sw6 didn't impress me when it comes to midbass or even midrange for that matter. They are nice speakers but not 650 dollars nice. My AP Arians beat them in every way :) Congrats on finding those great speaks!
 
#4 · (Edited)
OP -
You might try the Reveal model Tannoy for spec's on the 6" woofer/mid. The Reveal model line was brought into the Tannoy product lineup in the mid '90's. The woofer/mid unit pictured appears to be a magnetically shielded version.
For the longest time Tannoy products were centered around their "dual concentric" driver arrangement. Tannoy was sold from Goodman Inc. in the mid '90s and is now owned by a group which also owns t.c. Electronic and others. Our Brands | TC Group
 
#5 ·
At one time I was looking at the Elate 6 driver and did a straight swap between my then Hertz ML165 and this one. I was shocked at how there seemed to be almost zero midbass. My Hertz stomped all over them in this regard. The Morel did seem very well built and an attractive design but noone will ever see them in my setup. I now have the mw265 8 inch Morel drivers and they are a whole different animal. Awesome midbass and surprising smooth midrange up to even over 2 kHz. I cut mine down around 500 Hz however as I'm using them in a strict midbass roll. Damned good for less than $200/pair in my hand brand spankin' new. You can't even get half an Elate for that.:rolleyes:
 
#10 ·
Sound
Amplifier used is a NVX JAD 900.5 supplying 60rms at 4 ohms and unspecified at 8 ohms.



Conclusion

I feel like an idiot for spending so much money on the SW6. The Tannoys were a diamond in the rough.

The Elates are recognized as subwoofers and not woofers, they are speced to absorb up to 200watts - that is a declaration even higher than a Seas Lotus SW300i (and that is a 12 inch)

And you amp them with a 60watt RMS channel???

Try again!

This time give them 150watts, 200watts heck give them 400watts

I think your opinion about them will change.

As well try to put them in a seald box between 7-12 liters

I think your opinion about them will change.


60 watts on SW6 should sound like hell.
 
#13 ·
That tannoy driver looks like the one in there more recent mini monitors,I forget the model,I know the passive monitor is red the active is blue..morel has some impressive speaker manufacturing capabilities..but in my opinion tannoy makes some of the best drivers i have ever heard,only problem is that they don't sell them :( a couple years ago I got my hands on some tannoy 15" dual concentric drivers with alnico motors that are used in there prestige series and after a year of learning to build tapered horn cabinets I finally got a chance to enjoy listening to them,AMAZING DRIVERS :))))